
Locally Owned and Operated Award Winning Handcrafted Cheesecakes Baked Fresh Daily with the Finest Ingredients since 2007
Locally Owned and Operated Award Winning Handcrafted Cheesecakes Baked Fresh Daily with the Finest Ingredients since 2007
Chrisoula's Cheesecakes are made From Scratch Daily with the Freshest and Finest Ingredients. Always Fresh, Never Frozen!
Our minis and personal size cheesecakes are most popular and in stock daily. Our larger whole cheesecakes are made to the order. Please allow 2-3 business days notice. Ask about Gluten Free or KETO Friendly options.
Scroll down for online ordering, reviews and recognition, about us, a printable menu and directions to our store in beautiful downtown Pensacola.
Thank you for visiting! We hope to see you soon!
By Kimberlee Moore July 30, 2020 "Our Top Ten Places to get Authentic Cheesecake in Florida"
By Steve Spears June 6, 2018. "Favorite Dessert Spots Around Florida"
Chrisoula's Signature Flavors-
• Amaretto
• Banana Pudding
• Black Forest
• Blueberry
• Cherry
• Chocolate Swirl
• Dark Chocolate
• Dark Chocolate Praline
• German Chocolate
• Key Lime
• Oreo
• Original
• Peanut Butter
• Praline
• Salted Caramel
• Strawberry
• Turtle
• White Chocolate Raspberry
• Seasonal/Monthly Flavors: June- Orangesicle
Mini Cheesecakes
Our Mini Cheesecakes have become the Most Popular and are Available Daily. These Delicious Servings are Just Right for Any Occasion- Weddings, Bridal Showers, Baby Showers, Birthday Parties and More!
Single Mini $3
Six Minis $17
Twelve Minis $32
Personal Size Cheesecakes
Our Personal Size Cheesecakes are Available Daily in Most of Our
Signature Flavors. Perfect for 1 or 2 people.
Single $8
Larger Whole Cheesecakes
Our Larger Whole Cheesecakes are Made Fresh to the Order. Please Allow 2-3 Business Days Notice for your Delicious Chrisoula’s Handcrafted Whole Cheesecake. Pre-Order from Three Sizes:
Medium 6-8 servings $30-$40
Large 10-12 servings $40-$50
Extra Large 14-16 servings $52-$62
Follow us on Facebook, Instagram & Twitter
Third Party Delivery Services
ASAP (formerly Waitr)
Store Hours
Mon-Thurs 11am-4pm
Friday 11am-5pm.
Downtown Pensacola
236 W Garden St #2A
Pensacola, FL 32502
850-438-5650
Note: We currently are not serving lunch- soup, salad and sandwiches.
Menu and Prices Subject to Change
By Steve Spears June 6, 2018
"Favorite Dessert Spots Around Florida"
By Marisa Roman
Posted in Florida January 29, 2019
"Chrisoula's Cheesecake Shoppe In Florida"
By Kimberlee Moore July 30, 2020
"Our Top Ten Places to get Authentic Cheesecake in Florida"
Click Here To Order E-GIFT CARDS
Chrisoula is a Pensacola native with Greek heritage. She grew up in the restaurant business with her family in Pensacola. Her father Spero Athanasios was chef/owner of The Angus Steak Ranch, Boy On A Dolphin and Cafe 22. Her career in hospitality started as a hostess at the Boy. She always loved to make desserts and Greek pastries since she was young. In 2003, her husband Tony asked for a homemade chocolate chip cheesecake with fresh strawberries for his birthday, and he loved it. She made cheesecakes for family during holidays and special occasions. In 2005, she started making them at her family's restaurant in downtown Pensacola, Cafe 22. It has been a hit in the Pensacola and surrounding areas ever since. She and her husband Tony opened the first storefront in April 2007 in Pensacola on Cervantes near Scenic Hwy and currently serve cheesecake at their downtown Pensacola location since November 2014. Tony is also a Pensacola native, he left his corporate management job with Grainger Industrial Supply after 19 years in 2014 to help manage and grow the business. Chrisoula has a very unique background, writings of the first cheesecake created was on the Greek island of Samos, Greece, where her father is from. She takes pride in creating the freshest and finest cheesecake, as it should be, Always! Chrisoula's has received many awards, high ratings and has been in many publications with her work. "We keep our cheesecakes fresh, always, never frozen." Stop by and see what everyone is talking about.
We are honored to receive these awards and recognition.
*Florida Travel + Life Favorite Dessert Spots Around Florida
*OnlyInYourState.com Chrisoula's Cheesecake Shoppe In Florida
*AuthenticFlorida.com Our Top Ten Places to get Authentic Cheesecake in Florida
*Best of Florida 2022 Regional Winner Bakeries Category
*VIP Pensacola Magazine Best Desserts & Wedding Cake/Confections
*In Weekly Best of the Coast Best Desserts & Best Pastries
*Pensacola News Journal Best of the Bay Best Desserts
*Pensacola Chamber 2018 Small Business of the Year
*Pensacola Chamber 2017 Small Business of the Month
*TripAdvisor Certificate of Excellence
*Yelp Award Recipient People Love Us on Yelp
Store Hours
Mon-Thurs 11am-4pm
Friday 11am-5pm